Grammar Practice:
Mechanical and Communicative
Andrew Wright ILI International Languages Institute
Copyright not Copy Wright
These notes are copyright not Copy Wright.
If you would like to use them with your own students, please do so without telling me. If you would like to publish them or part of them then email me and tell me about it. I am almost certainly going to say, Yes!
But you must agree to acknowledge my name and website. If you don’t, it is plagiarism, unfair and theft of my intellectual property.
andrew@ili.hu
‘Communicative grammar practice’, means: focussing on a grammatical point and using it
purposefully, appropriately and accurately.
Mechanical or communicative?
Mechanical
The st thinks about the form much more than the meaning.
Communicative
The st thinks about the meaning more than the form.
My opinion
Students need both…sometimes it is a relief to just concentrate on the form. Cf football training or musical instrument training…both make use of ‘mechanical training’. But we need to experience the new language as well. Cf football…regularly play a real match.
Examples of traditional mechanical practice activities
1 Multiple choice (choose one of several choices)
2 Gap filling (fill in the gaps in a text)
3 True/false (read or listen and decide what is true and what is not true)
4 Asking questions etc but not really bothering about what the st says only how he/she says it. (This is phoney communicative practice)
Example of phoney communicative practice which is really mechanical
Teacher: What did you do last weekend?
Student: I swim across Lake Balaton.
Teacher: I swam across Lake Balaton. Repeat.
Student: I swam across Lake Balaton.
My opinion
If the teacher appears to be asking real questions but doesnt show any interest in the content of the answer then it is a mechanical practice activity.
My opinion is that it is better to do purely mechanical activities than phoney communicative activities.
Finding communicative activities which focus on a grammatical point
(This article will not refer to mechanical practice again)
The art of communicative language teaching
…is to introduce as many genuinely communicative activities as possible which, at the same time, give good practice in the grammatical point.
How can the teacher do this? In this article there are several families of ideas for getting communicative activities going in the classroom so that the teacher and students can be teachers and students of English but also human being sharing experiences together through English.
Five criteria for judging a communicative activity
1 Does it engage the students?
2 Do the students experience the language in use? Do they care about the content?
3 Do all the students take part?
4 Is it easy for you to organise?
5 Is it easy for you to prepare?
Twelve sources of communicative activities
In these notes I have noted down 12 sources of communicative activities which might set your mind going. I hope you find them practical!
………………………………………………………………………………………………
1 Real life situations
You have been given a topic and a language item or skill to teach…
First of all, think of yourself as a person with people rather than as a teacher with students.
What might you all enjoy doing together related to the topic you have to take and activities in which language has a key part to play?
Brainstorm lots of activities. If you don’t find any which involve the language item you are supposed to work on then it is either because you have not brainstormed enough OR because that topic and that language item do not collocate!
Questions and answers (and other exchanges) in which the teacher shows genuine interest in what the st is saying.
Teacher: What did you do last weekend?
Student: I swim across Lake Balaton.
Teacher: You swam across Lake Balaton? But that is amazing! How long did it take you? Have you done that before?
Recent tightening of airport security…we had to take off our shoes…a mother had to drink half he baby’ milk to prove that it was not bomb making material…we couldn’t even take a book on board…we couldn’t take a bottle of water on board…
What to do in an emergency…leads to imperative forms…you must…then…
Hearing about an accident…have you ever been in an accident…what happened?
Entering a lottery…leads to ‘would…if…’
Comparing prices in two countries…in H 1 kilo of bananas cost x and in E they cost y….more/less expensive
Guinness Book of Records: comparatives and superlatives plus past simple and a time marker.
Trying to identify something which is difficult to identify: I think it might be/is probably…
You have a different perception of time to another person…do some experiments trying to judge the passage of time: I think it took/was about 9 seconds. Ditto guessing distance, quantity, weight, colour, number, etc.
Some people are good at using maps and some are not: you go down to the first cross roads and then turn right…drawing maps and comparing them…
Talking about changes in society or in a town: there used to be/people used to…now…Korosfoi utca used to be the edge of town so they put the cemetery there.
Looking at a holiday brochure and talking about where to go: would/wouldn’t…because…I think my parents might like to….
Looking at a tourist brochure and talking about choosing, designing and writing the images/information given: I wouldn’t have chosen x …I would have chosen y. If I designed a brochure for Manchester I would…
Discussing a healthy diet: I usually eat/drink/etc. I should really….
Discussing England: It is not one thing…on the one hand x but on the other hand y…
Comparing daily habits: I get up at about x…so while I am getting up you are still sleeping.
Making someone relax: Use imperatives to tell them what to do. Sit comfortably. Close your eyes. Relax your legs. Feel your chest relaxing. Etc.
Mail order catalogue: what would you buy? Which one would you buy? Which would your mother buy/like to have. If you bought your partner a present which one would you buy?
Unexpected, ambiguous, unpleasant phone call: who might it have been…why might he have said such things…what might I have said…
A glimpse of someone through the classroom window (or a magazine photo): Who might he be…where might he be going…what might he be thinking about/worrying about….what has he been doing…what will he do next…
Photo of an unspecified place or happening. Speculating about where it might be and what might be happening or have happened: might be/could be…probably…definitely…on the other hand…
Where would you like to be if you were not here? …inviting your companion to share day dreams.
What is your day like? Showing interest in someone else’s life…What time do you get up/go to work/arrive at work, etc.
Godollo is changing so quickly! It used to be…There used to be…An office block has been built…the old road to Budapest was constructed in…the blocks of flats were built in…the Sony factory was built in…3000 workers are employed by Sony…The university has been made into the biggest university in Hungary…it used to be…The palace was given to the Hapsburgs in 1865…it was loved by Sissy…Sissy was loved by the Hungarian people…
Personal feelings and experiences. Tell the students a precise date in the last five years and ask them to tell each what they were doing. Ask your students to say what they would do if they lost their job/learned that they must have a serious operation/quarrelled with their best friends.
Personal interests. The student talks about a topic that you and/or the other students don’t know so much about.
……………………………………………………………………………………………..
2 Surveys
The same set of questions can be used again and again with the intention of collecting information for a survey. Eg What’s your favourite colour? Whats your favourite music? Do you feel there is any hope for the world? What are the main threats to our existence, Etc. Providing this is a survey into an area of interest to the students, it is communicative.
Note that my examples range from the limited in both content and language and the startlingly unlimited in asking huge questions! What do you want to do?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
3 Games
My new revised edition of ‘Games for Language Learning’ has more games and variations in it than any other collection of games! If you can take one book when you go to teach in China then take ‘Games for Language Learning’!
Here are a few of the 400 games and variations in the book…
Is it true?
The st talks about things he/she did last weekend and the other students decide which were true and which were not true.
Miming
One student mimes and the others guess what he/she is doing. Are you swimming, etc.
Twenty questions
One st thinks of a subject and the others have twenty questions to find out what it is.
What’s the sketch
A st sketches on the blackboard and the others try to find out what it is by asking questions.
Add a word
St A says a word. St B adds a word. St C adds a word. The aim is to make a sentence and then to build up a story. Very good for general revision but particularly for word order.
(For a wide variety of games to use see: Games for Language Learning, CUP. Also Five Minute Activities, CUP.
Mouse hiding in the room. Where is the mouse? Is it under….prepositions.
……………………………………………………………………………………………..
4 Challenges
The student is challenged to:
Identify something which is difficult to identify (a picture flashed at great speed)
Find a connection between two bits of information (two texts or a text and a picture)
Find a way of grouping various bits of information
Put various bits of information into an order of value
Put various bits of information into a developmental sequence
Remember various bits of information
The teacher and other students respond to the content of the challenge and not to the form.
Many activities based on challenge offer intense grammatical focus without taking away from the communicative intent.
My book, ‘Pictures for Language Learning’, published by CUP offers 415 activities using pictures based on the idea of ‘challenges’.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………
5 Dialogues
Basically two approaches:
1 Repeating and/or adapting a dialogue you give them.
2 Inventing a dialogue based on some kind of starting point which you give them.
…………………………………………………………………………………………………….
6 Drama
There are many drama games given in ‘Drama Techniques in Language Learning’, published by Cambridge University Press.
…………………………………………………………………………………………….
7 Writing poetry
You may think I am out of my mind in suggesting the writing of poetry related to grammar practice! Oh no! Not at all! The opposite! Rich stuff for grammar practice!
Writing poems which are based on a key sentence pattern.
1 I used to…but now I ….
2 First of all I saw the sea
Then I heard the waves on the shore
Then I saw you lying on your towel
Then I heard your song.
Then I felt the wind on my cheeks
And tasted the salt sea air.
3 pres simple and continuous
Usually I work in an office.
I get up at six o’clock,
Put on my suit,
Have breakfast,
Get to work by eight o’clock.
But today!
Today!
I am dancing!
And singing!
And kissing!
And drinking delicate wines!
And …living.
Check out:
Inward Ear published by CUP
Creative Poetry Writing by OUP
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
8 Telling stories and making stories
This is a very rich family of activities mainly open communicative fluency but it can have something of a grammatical focus eg use of past tenses.
See my books published by OUP:
Storytelling with Children
Creatiing Stories with Children
See Rinvolucri and Morgan published by CUP
Once Upon a Time
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
9 Songs
Songs are engaging, have a fixed text which is repeated every time the song is sung. Some publishers have commissioned songs exemplifying grammatical points. See Carolyn Graham’s, Jazz Chants published by OUP (mainly for young people)
…………………………………………………………………………………………….
10 Pictures
Pictures are stimulating and potentially full of information and potentially emotionally moving.
If you want to use pictures and want some ideas then check out my two books:
Pictures for Language Learning. CUP
Essentially, in this book, I give 415 ways of using pictures guided by the idea of Challenges (see above)
1000 Pictures for Teachers to Copy. Longman
This book is meant for photocopying or for supporting your own drawing. There is a concise summary of ways of using pictures in the introduction.
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
11 A medium eg paper
Paper, string, blackboards, windows, doors, tiles, the sun…things in your environment…can all offer subjects for language teaching.
Paper
Paper can be folded, cut, torn, glued, coloured, etc.
Paper/cards: matching sentences/phrases or LI/L2 words or L2 words and pictures.
Paper fortune teller (perfect for contextualising and practising future tense forms)
See my folding paper devices in Pictures for Language Learning, CUP.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………
12 Teaching English by Magic
Magic tricks certainly engage people and language can have a crucial role. The demonstration of the trick presents the new language items and then the explanation of the trick and the student practising doing the trick acts as a wonderful form of drill practice in which meaning matters but the language remains the same.
I am finishing the list of sources with magic because I would like to share the idea that anything which is interesting and involves language is potentially language teaching and learning material.
Example (text only…trick demo in the workshop)
I’m going to pick up the coin but I’m not going to pick up the paper.
Kaboom!
Have a look (stooge lifts the paper)
I picked up the coin but I didnt picked up the paper. She did.
Other things to think about…
My dear colleagues! Maybe you can’t cope with thinking about anything else…nevertheless the fact is that there are lots of other issues…
1 Learnng styles.
In the last ten years a lot has been said about the different ways in which people learn best. The teacher as an individual has his/her preferences which may not coincide with those of some/all of the students preferences.
The teachers job is to provide a balanced diet of activities catering for these different learning styles…
Different sts need different things…
see things (pictures, diagrams, the written word),
hear things (different voices, tapes, music),
feel things (word cards, real objects)
move (mime, standing up, feeling rhythm)
analyse and hypothesise (speculate about grammatical points before being told)
be told clearly and authoritatively (listen to and study grammatical explanations)
create and play with language (combine similar sounding words, make poetry, make stories)
have a go with language and clear up mistakes later
get the points right first and then have a go
work by themselves
work with others
have a global experience first and then go into detail
study detail and then experience a bigger situation
2 Motivating the learners to want to listen/read and speak/write
Be interested in them and show it. (Their experiences, feelings, ideas. You show your interest with your body and face and, of course, by your verbal responses to what they say and do)
Invite them to share experiences, feelings and ideas and respond as full human beings.
Challenge them. (Can you identify x? What is this strange object?)
Offer useful information. (Best place to buy airtickets, etc. How to make better use of their memory)
Astonish them with amazing information.
Provoke them with assertions. (Women drivers! Alphabetism is unacceptable! Spiders are wonderful!)
Provoke them with questions, mysteries, dilemmas.
Stir them with drama and stories.
Invite their natural ability to hypothesise rather than just be told.
Offer a wide range of types of experience. (visual, audial, kinaesthetic, abstract, naturalistic, serious, funny, holistic, details, analysing, creating)
Show your delight in your cup being half full not glumness that it is half empty.
Foster self esteem and independence. (The learners should not feel dependent on you for their development…they should know how to learn)
3 Class management re practice activities
Teacher asks the class a question…chooses one st to answer.
Teacher asks the class a question and tells the sts to tell their neighbour the answer…then asks for answers from several sts.
Teachers ask a question…indiv sts write down their answer…then compare with one neighbour then compare with another pair…then have class discussion.
Get st to take over the Ts questioning role.
4 Correcting student errors
If an activity is genuinely communicative YOU will give respect to what the st is trying to say. Normally you will not correct him/her while he/she is speaking. You may do it just by repeating what he/she has said but in correct English.
5 Different dialects of English. What is correct?
My opinion
We should teach the dialect which the sts need in order to achieve what it is that they want. For example, the correct English might be the English of the examiners and examination board they are planning to submit themselves to. It is highly unlikely that the correct dialect is the regional dialect from where the teacher happens to come from in the UK…according to this criterion.
6 Teachers Resource Books
In the last 30 years a huge number of resource books, filled with grammar practice activities, have been published. Amazingly some teachers don’t seem to know anything about them! It is a bit like a professional cook sticking to salt and pepper and ignoring the potential of all the other herbs and spices!
Resource books cost roughly the same as 1/2 hours teaching time but provide 100/150 activities you can use for years! They are incredibly inexpensive if you value your time.
By all means use the text books and also create your own materials but to ignore the existence of resource books is like not buying a map or a tourist guide of places to see.
7 Here are my own resource books which are still in print
Games for Language Learning. CUP
Pictures for Language Learning. CUP
Five Minute Actvities. CUP
Storytelling with Children. OUP
Creating Stories with Chidlren. OUP
Art and Crafts with Children. OUP
1000 Pictures for Teachers to Copy. Longman
Creativity in the Classroom. ILI Godollo
8 Here is a quick selection of others I recommend
Penny Ur. Grammar Practice Activities. CUP
Mario Rinvolucri. Grammar Games. CUP
Mario Rinvolucri Grammar in Action Again Prentice Hall
Mario Rinvolucri. Dictation. CUP
Jill Hadfield. Communication Games. Longman
Postcript
But mechanical activities in which the content is not important for the students ARE also useful, part of the time. Just sitting in the car and feeling the clutch and the brake…or just putting the car into gear and not having to be on a public road and think about the traffic, is a relief! But the idea that someone should get their driving licence without driving on a public road is ridiculous!
We need both mechanical and communicative activities.
Keep in touch with ILI!
We hope you have found these notes useful!
We hope you will have a rich, happy and rewarding life in ELT or ESL!
We hope you will keep in touch with us at ILI International Languages Institute in Godollo, Hungary.
When you have done a few years of teaching we hope you will
come on our 50 hour course:
LCCI Arels
Certificate for Teaching Business English (Cert TEB)
With
Mark Powell
Our contact addresses:
Julia Dudas info@ili.hu
Andrew Wright andrew@ili.hu
We have been running this course for 5 years with the top lecturer in the world in this area, Mark Powell. We have had teachers from all over the world, from Japan, from South Africa, from the Emirates and, of course, from all the European countries. If you come from another EU country you don’t even have to pay. It’s madness!
50 hours in 8 days and you get an internationally recognised certificate from the London Chamber of Commerce and Industry, LCCI!
Amazing!
most excellent, thank you!
Lucy, delighted you ffound it useful. Do you want to come to my internet seminar on Sunday …costs nothing! Stories in Business. Heres my attachment…it tells you what to do and where to go. Andrew
Hi Andrew!
Wow! It feels so special to have a response from you, I have your books “Games for Language Learning” and all my students have benefited from it tremendously.
I am in Costa Rica working with adult and teen students. Previously I worked for an institution as a supervisor and teacher trainer, now I have gone back to basics, and have ‘cut free’ from course books and BIG groups and am free to explore student-centered communicative classes. EVERYTHING you include here resonates deeply in what I am trying – and sometimes actually achieving! – to do.
I would LOVE to come to your seminar – not sure how it will work as I am in Costa Rica and may not have internet connection on Sunday – ha! – but I would love to try – however unfortunately I can’t seem to locate the attachment – could I trouble you to send it to my email: lucytoner@gmail.com ?
thank you so much! and keep on shining the way!
regards
lucy
Great, this can be exactly what my wife and I required to learn
Best wishes to you both!
Andrew
As soon as I noticed this internet site I went on reddit to share some of the love with them.
I am happy to hear it but how do you apply my ideas when you seem to be making canvas shoes?
Andrew
Thanks to your blog loaded with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to acquire what I was looking for.
Delighted to be of help.
Andrew
I was suggested this blog by means of my bro. I am not sure whether or not this publish is written by means of him as no one else understand such precise about my problem. You’re wonderful! Thanks!
Thank you.
Andrew
Wow! This could be one particular of the most useful blogs We’ve ever arrive across on this subject.Basically Great.I’m also a specialist in this topic therefore I can understand your effort
Wonderful! Thank you!
Andrew
Outstanding post, you have pointed out some excellent points , I as well believe this s a very superb website.your link on my blog here http://www.conveyancingquotes.info/?page_id=9 ,
Thank you…I dont know how to put links on my site I will ask my technical friend next time I see him.
Andrew
While this subject can be very touchy for most people, my opinion is that there has to be a middle or common ground that we all can find. I do appreciate that youve added relevant and intelligent commentary here though. Thank you!
Delighted you find my ideas to be of some relevance to you. Thank you for telling me.
Andrew
Hi there! I know this is kinda off topic however I’d figured I’d ask. Would you be interested in exchanging links or maybe guest writing a blog article or vice-versa? My blog addresses a lot of the same subjects as yours and I think we could greatly benefit from each other. If you might be interested feel free to send me an email. I look forward to hearing from you! Excellent blog by the way!
I clicked on your homepage and found a huge ad for home theatre systems…why do you say what you said in your text?
I only wanted to create a word in an effort to say as a consequence of you for most of the lovely ideas that you’re showing here. My much time internet homework has at the end been paid for with skilled knowledge to talk about with my own two close friends. I ‘d show that most people site visitors are fortunate to stay a great community by means of many brilliant people who have great recommendations. I believe really privileged to enjoy seen your blog page and count on so much more enjoyable times reading in this case. Thanks again for many people things.
Please call in again!
Andrew
Wow nice post! Thanks for sharing, keep on going!.
Thank you!
Andrew
Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it is truly informative. I’m going to watch out for brussels. I’ll be grateful if you continue this in future. Many people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!
Brussels??? Please tell me what you are referring to.
Andrew
Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it is really informative. I’m going to watch out for brussels. I will appreciate if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!
Great! But what does your referene to Brussels refer to?
Andrew
Hello, I love this site just thought i’d let you know 😀
And I DO appreciate your saying so.
Andrew
Happy to hear it!
Andrew
Drastically, the article is actually the foremost on this particular worthy matter. I concur with your decisions and often will thirstily look forward to see a person’s approaching upgrades. Saying thanks will never just be adequate, for the phenomenal lucidity within your writing. I may at as soon as grab ones own feeds to remain informed involving any tweets. Delightful work and much success within your business opportunities! Have a nice day.
Thank you! I have to be lucid otherwise I wouldn’t understand it myself.
Andrew
Appreciation with this interesting writing. Ever since I commenced specializing in understanding much more of this topic, my over-all life has better tremendously. I are looking at the choice of adding the opposite thing to my career for about a year. For a nice and pleased with the kind of information I have got gained from various websites, especially your own property. I have a smaller budget to extremely obtain ebooks and movies but your site a great help to me.
Happy to have of some help.
Andrew
I dugg some of you post as I thought they were very useful very useful
Great!
Andrew
Excellent post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed! Very useful information particularly the remaining phase 🙂 I care for such info a lot. I used to be seeking this particular info for a very long. Thanks and good luck.
What ‘remaining phase’ are you referring to?
Andrew
It’s really a great and helpful piece of information. I am glad that you shared this useful information with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.
Delighted.
Andrew
You could definitely see your skills in the work you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers like you who aren’t afraid to say how they believe. All the time follow your heart.
I will try to do that.
Andrew
Thankyou for helping out, excellent info .
Thank you for tellng me.
Andrew
realy look at this page..
http://www.hoekanikrijkworden.eu.
please tell me what you mean…
Andrew
Very great post. I just stumbled upon your blog
and wanted to mention that I have really enjoyed browsing your
weblog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing on your rss feed and I am hoping you write again very soon!
Happy you like the site! Please tell me what it is that you do. Andrew
Hey There. I found your blog using msn.
This is a really well written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information. Thanks for the post. I will definitely return.
You are welcome! Andrew
Spray insulating allows for maximum results in preventing air infiltration problems,
which in turn can save on energy costs. The net
described fast cooking times, low fuel consumption and high heat retention brought about
by sturdy design and deep layers of insulation, whereas local suppliers were quoting themes of ease of installation and lowest cost purchase prices
for what were essentially ovens with virtually no insulation and a very substandard level
of finish. If you feel though that you’re just not comfortable enough, then there may be a couple of simple tips you can use to supplement what your home already has.
Hi, Awesome write-up. It comes with an problem with all your web-site in world-wide-web adventurer, may click here? For example is still the marketplace leader and also a significant portion of folks will leave your great producing therefore problem.
Howdy terrific website! Does running a blog such as this require a massive amount work?
I have no understanding of programming however I was hoping to
start my own blog soon. Anyways, if you have any suggestions or
techniques for new blog owners please share. I understand
this is off topic nevertheless I simply wanted to ask.
Thanks a lot!
I am ingnorant about these things…somebody helped me to set it up ina few minutes.
Hi there, I enjoy reading through your article post.
I like to write a little comment to support you.
I really loved your writing. Keep writing more !
Delighted! Andrew
Here you can find some tips:
https://www.facebook.com/pages/English-Grammar/674308762597366
Hi, I do believe tthis is an excellent site. I stumbledupon it 😉 I will
revisit yet again since i have book-marked it.
Money and freedom is the best way to change, may youu be rich and continue to
guide other people.
Thanking you for wodetful and useful information for a English language teacher.
Thhe diamond engagement rings are made with such passion that they immpart
grace and beauty to you. Types of engagement ring include Cathedral,
which features a raised gemstone, Halo, whiich features one
large diamond surrounded by many smaller ones, and Solitaire,
arguably the most poppular variety, which carries one large, magnificent
diamond. Hence, for some couples, it is best to keep the engagement ring simlle since as per Nicky
Oppenheimer (De Beer’s chairman), diamonds have no value edcept
filling the psychological need of its recipient.
This design is steller! You certainly know how to keep a reader amused.
Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to
start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Wonderful job.
I really loved what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it.
Too cool!
HTZL Projects,
Sumish Darak,
Omega, Senjska ul.
Karlovac,
Pin: 47000
Croatia
Hi Andrew!!
OMG!!! I’ve spent dozens of sites searching for an understandable writing on this topic, but non got me satisfied like your notes. Excellent!!
Most thank you.